Best Golf Putter Headcovers Review

Protecting an investment or just being overly fussy in a community that cares about every little detail almost obsessive-compulsively? The opinions on whether you need a headcover for your putter are divided, but the majority of golfers wouldn’t discount it outright. With that in mind, in this best golf putter headcovers review we’ll be discussing just that - the best golf putter headcovers, why you need them, and where to find one.

What is a Putter Head Cover? 

The primary use for a head cover would be protection in transit or in storage. This will prevent any accidental nicks, dents, or scratches on the clubface that may affect your short game. Come to think of it, keeping your putter inside a cover is a huge deal if you mean to resale it.

Depending on the configuration of your bags, you might want to keep the headcover on your putter(s) even during a round. This applies especially if you’re taking the cart, which counts as transit as far as many golfers are concerned. Then again, seeing you’re using it for each and every hole, it can be a real hassle to slip it off and then back on every time (of course, not everyone will feel this way).

Another reason, funny as it may sound, is camouflage. Say you have a vintage putter, or have invested a goodly amount of money in a new one. A headcover, as unassuming as possible, would be just another precautionary step against stealing. Of course, it won’t discourage a determined thief, but it will deter any “casuals”. Also, if the former, many might want to buy it, so this way you can avoid discussing the matter to an extent.

Finally, it just makes the bag looks nice (well, nice-r at any rate) and lets you bring in a touch of fun in an otherwise sombre sport (at least when you’re having a bad round it’s like that). On a more serious note, club covers do make it easier to distinguish one bag from another (it happens to the best of us).

What To Look For

Now, how to choose the best golf putter cover is an entirely different matter, since it’s even more down to personal preferences than choosing a putter. When shopping for one, there are four (and a half) things to keep an eye on – covering, lining, padding, and closures (and stitches). Most throw-in (OEM) covers will be vinyl or neoprene with Velcro closures and medium padding (not enough to feel reassuring, but sufficient to actually protect the putter from damage).

Best Golf Putter Headcover Comparison Table

Best Golf Putter Headcover Review

To save you the trouble, we did the legwork and made a list of the 21 best golf putter headcover makers. Assuming you’re looking for a more personalized gear, we didn’t include any OEMs and their proprietary covers. On that note, we should mention that many golfers favour Titleist and Adams Golf (they make covers for TaylorMade).

Daphne’s has become a household name when it comes to putter covers, and club covers in general. The company has been around for so long and has done business so successfully that you’d be hard-pressed to find a major store without their headcovers.

The company used to cooperate with Nike and have done commercials together, which speaks volumes in and of itself. On that note, they have a lot of PGA pros sporting their gear, such as Tiger Woods and Dustin Johnson, to name but a couple. They have a wide range of covers you can choose from, mostly animals, plush, and cuddly like the real deal.

Stitch Golf is another popular choice among golfers looking for putter covers, and for good reason. Whether you’re going for a leather or a knit headcover, you’re guaranteed quality and superb stitching (pun intended). The leather part of their range is virtually indestructible.

The covers should be a good fit, with no bunching, thanks to the built-in elastic that lets you tighten it around the club. However, the real selling point is their durability, both on the leather covers and Merino-wool-knit ones.

You’ll hear a great deal of good stuff about Delilah and her putter covers, or club covers in general. On that note, don’t be fooled by the site’s name – these covers are for everyone’s flatstick. It takes some time for your custom order to be finished and shipped (at least a month), which is a minor gripe.

On the flipside, you’re pretty much guaranteed to receive a quality putter cover to your exact description. On that note, if you don’t have a touch of creativity, Delilah will try to design it for you (based on your input), and send the design for approval before crafting it.

What happens when you take a very niche market and specialize in it until you become the standard? Well, Jan Craig happens. OK, fanboying aside, with over half a century of experience under their collective belt, Jan Craig is a company that has a lot to offer.

If you’re looking for knitted covers for your putter, this might just be the brand for you. The wool is thick and the seams are virtually unnoticeable, plus the covers will last you a good long while and hold their value quite well, in case you’re thinking of reselling.

They offer a choice between buying a premade cover or designing your own, but given the fact there aren’t any putter covers in stock, you’re left with the latter option for flatsticks. 

If customer service is a big part of your shopping experience, then you might want to write down the following email: jujumc@charter.net (don’t worry, it’s legitimate). It’s worth noting that there is no official site, which is pretty much it when it comes to gripes.

As for the praises, we’ll start with personal and prompt service (Ju Ju handles all her clients personally). It used to be that the order took three days to come from your head to your doorstep, her popularity has skyrocketed in recent years, so the wait period may be longer.

If you like the vintage looks and have some surplus money to splash around, you might want to check out Bert LaMar’s Iliac putter covers. As noted, they’re quite expensive, almost the price of a putter, but the quality is undeniable.

All covers are made of genuine leather with wool lining, so there’s no question they’ll do a great job of protecting your flatstick or lasting a good long while.

On that note, they also hold their value, so reselling them is a lucrative option.

Rocket Tour is another major name when it comes to putter headcovers and golf covers in general.

It’s perfect for those of you with an eye on a retro-style head cover (especially if you like knitted headcovers).

As far as putter covers specifically go, you can have them in three distinct flavours (with more variations per flavour, of course) – Argyle, Racer, and Victory Stripe.

Other Makers that Deserve an Honourable Mention

There are plenty of headcover manufacturers that we couldn’t mention in detail and stay concise, so we’ll include them down here, with links to their respective sites. On that note, you’ll notice we didn’t include any OEMs. That isn’t to say major brands don’t offer custom covers, or that all of their covers are… unpleasant to look at.

The list:

Bespoke Golf USA (www.bespokegolfusa.com)

Craftsman Golf (www.craftsmangolf.com)

Creative Covers for Golf (www.creativecoversforgolf.com)

Cru Golf (www.crugolf.com)

Dormie Custom Covers (www.dormieworkshop.com)

Just4Golf (www.just4golf.com)

Mannkrafted (www.mannkrafted.com)

Patrick Gibbons Handmade (www.patrickgibbonshandmade.com)

Rose & Fire (www.roseandfire.com)

Seamus Golf Co. (www.seamusgolf.com)

Stealth Club Covers (www.stealthclubcovers.com)

Sumi-G (www.sumi-g.com)

Team Golf (www.teamgolfusa.com/)

Conclusion

And there you have it, top seven makers of custom headcovers for putters, with a little bit of something for everyone. We also added about the same number of other makers we didn’t have enough space to describe in more detail, so if you have the time and the will, be sure to check out their sites before reaching a decision.

That said, we realize that choosing the perfect head cover isn’t as crucial to your short game as choosing the right flatstick (talk about understatements), but it’s still an investment. So, by all means, if you have any stories featuring one or more of the names we mentioned, leave us a comment. Also, if you want to add a name, feel free to do that, as well. Until then, fairways and greens to you!